Saturday, October 19, 2019

The Dravidian Fantasy as History and the Mythical Kumarikandam as Geography

For a backgrounder, read the following essays:

  1. How the Dravidianists Ravaged the Tamil Heritage and Gifted Tamil Nadu to the Global Church
  2. An Encounter with a 55 BCE Lemurian alias Dravidian alias Periyarist
  3. How the Dravidianists Invented Kalabhras and Poisoned Tamil Public Discourse

An important prerequisite to understand the Dravidian discourse since its earliest days is to understand the history and mythology of the ancient Tamil country.

According to this imaginary history and mythology, in ancient times (no Dravidian ideologue, intellectual or historian has given an approximate timeframe. It ranges anywhere between 15000 years to 6000 years in the past), the eastern, western and southern parts of today’s Kanyakumari were attached to a sweeping and vast tract of land known as Lemuria or Kumari Nadu or Kumari Kandam. Now, this vast tract of land was subsequently submerged in the sea. The Tamils who survived this catastrophe migrated northwards.

And then in a short period, these Tamils migrated further northwards and occupied all of India and also made the region of today’s Pakistan and Afghanistan as their home. The language they spoke in those days has today transformed into what is known as Brahui.

Our Dravidianists claim that because the Aryans invaded from outside, the ancient Tamils were exterminated from these northern parts of India. Further, because the invasion was unsuccessful in south of the Vindhyas, the Tamils lived in peace and prosperity in these regions.

Unshakeable Faith in Mythology as History

The Dravidianists repose enormous and unshakeable faith in this mythology. Proud and zealous Dravidianists even today continue to propagate the Kumarikandam or the Lemuria fantasy. The interested reader is urged to search YouTube for the keyword, “Kumari Kandam.” The results are interesting to say the least.

Because the first person to propound this theory was a blazing Dravidianist himself, this theory acquired additional resplendence.

Nakkeerar who wrote a commentary on the Ahapporul or Kalaviyal, a compendium containing sixty aphorisms, has described in detail the upheavals faced by the ancient Tamil country. The Ahapporul is said to be authored by Lord Shiva (Iraiyanaar) himself. However, A.V. Subrahmanya Iyer in The Story of Tamil Research [1959] argues that the commentary was not written by Nakkeerar but by an unknown author.

In any case, there is no unanimity regarding this commentator’s dating. Traditional Tamil scholars assign his date to the 8th Century CE while the scholars of the 1940s-70s armed with graduate and postgraduate degrees place him in the 13th Century CE. But because this sort of internal quarrel harms the larger (politico-ideological) cause of the Dravidianists, a sort of compromise was reached between these two warring groups: they placed the date of the commentary somewhere in the 10th and 11th Century CE.

But are there any historical proofs that show that the aforementioned vast tract of land was actually submerged in the sea? The average Dravidian ideologue or academician typically does not anticipate such a question. And in case he has the patience and wherewithal to actually answer it, the stock reply will be on these lines: “Why do you even doubt that this event happened? Our Kalittogai and Silappadikkaram (discussed later in this series) clearly mention that the land of the Pandyas was submerged in the sea. Why! The Bible itself contains instances of the Great Flood!” In case they still don’t have the patience or the wherewithal, one might receive the following answer: “Why do you ask these mischievous questions? Focus on your area of expertise. Don’t meddle in topics unrelated to you!”

There’s no clear answer as to when or whether the landmass named Lemuria existed and when it was submerged. It definitely existed in the fertile imagination of the Dravidianists and it was submerged at an unknown time. According to some Dravidianist scholars (for example, K.K. Pillai, 1969: A Social History of the Tamils, University of Madras), it existed 15000 years ago. There is no answer to the question of how the dating was arrived at.

Method of Argumentation

Equally, another question may be asked:

“Let’s agree that Lemuria existed and it existed 15000 years ago. But how can you be sure that all those who lived there were Tamils and only Tamils?”

“Your question is stupid!” is the stock answer from the typical traditional Dravidian scholar.

Dr. BGL Swamy cites a conversation he had with a college-educated Tamil who supplied an even nuanced answer: “Sir, it’s ironic that those who have studied science still ask such a question! For example, botanists and anthropologists teach lessons on prehistoric people and mention Pithecanthropus and Australopithecus. Likewise, why can’t there exist a classification named Lemuriopithecus denoting the inhabitants of Lemuria?”

Then, their spirit of adventure will paralyze the best of us, says Dr. Swamy: “How can one claim that Lemuria never existed? Because no literature, inscription or remnant that proves its existence has not been found today doesn’t mean it never existed! It definitely existed but perhaps it didn’t attract anybody’s notice. Therefore, no mention of it is available today. Isn’t this the right conclusion to make?”

This sort of argumentation might be valid when one argues for the sake of argument. But there’s something known as wisdom and discrimination.

Lemurian Monkey

One of the scholars who was appointed to write a section in the government-sponsored initiative to bring out a ten-volume “official” history of Tamil Nadu (Tamizh Nadu Varalaru) posed the Lemuria question in a different way to Dr. Swamy:

“Sir, is there a relationship between Lemuria and the Lemuroidea thing that is taught in textbooks?”

“I have a few books which contain the answers to your question. I’ll lend them to you.”

He hesitated. It was clear why. He hadn’t learnt English in the manner it should be learnt. Neither had he studied Biology and Anthropology. He said, “It’s ok sir, you can tell me the answer yourself.”

Dr. Swamy: “In which case, I’ll have to tell you the answers from the same books. And when I do that, you won’t believe me.”

“It’s ok sir. I’m willing to listen.”

Dr. Swamy replied: ‘“These books don’t have the answer to your question whether a landmass named Lemuria existed or no. But it is true that there is an animal species classified as Lemuroidea. They belong to a category of monkeys primarily found in Africa…” he walked out even before I could complete my sentence. But he didn’t stop at that. He made a loud noise proclaiming that “this Doctor Chaami [Dr. Swamy] is evil. He claims that Tamils descended from apes.” This clamour reached the ears of the Tamil scholars in my college as well.’

‘In such circumstances the Dravidianists act as if a spear has pierced them. They whip up a frenzy, organize protest meets and condemnation seminars. About eight to ten Dravidian scholars organized a meet and condemned “Doctor Chaami” with the choicest of obscenities in chaste Tamil. Then they sent a copy of their “decision note” that described how they were hurt by “Doctor Chaami’s” words.’”

What surprised Dr Swamy was not the note itself but the bundle of sheets attached to it. Every sheet was filled with nothing but signatures, and the total exceeded one thousand. Dr Swamy was left wondering how they managed to get hold of so many people to sign it.

Writer, author, and translator. Author of the bestselling "Tipu Sultan: The Tyrant of Mysore," "The Madurai Sultanate: A Concise History," and "Seventy Years of Secularism." English translator of Dr. S L Bhyrappa's blockbuster Kannada novel, "Aavarana".

Get The Dharma Dispatch in your Inbox!

Subscribe to receive The Dharma Dispatch directly in your email inbox.

- Before Related Stories Advertisement -

Related Stories

How the Secular Historians Transformed Punyabhumi Ayodhya into an International Crime Scene and Got Away With it

Preface Two key themes emerged from my scores of conversations with the people of Ayodhya on a fairly recent trip...

A Slice of Ramayana in Sri Rallapalli Anantakrishna Sarma’s Life

Of the numerous roads one can take in Tirupati to reach the foothills of the Tirumala mountain, one is adorned with the bronze...

The Contours of an India Before Nehruvian Secularism and an Impending Spiritual Loss

It is said that there’s nothing original that a human being can say that’s not already present in nature. It follows that even...

Sri Krishnadevaraya’s Empire of Fragrance and Food

Without doubt, Sri Krishnadevaraya was the greatest emperor of the Vijayanagar kingdom. And perhaps one of the greatest emperors that the...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here